This is part two of a two-part investigation into Bradford Council's 2027-28 savings plan. Part one looked at Cllr Ian Eglin, the Executive Member presenting it. Part two looks at what's in it. It's a long read with lots of nerdy detail, so settle in with a brew. For those in a hurry, here's the TL;DR:
2: Much of the £50m is accounting rather than cuts. That includes £3.85m tied to a packaging waste grant the Government hasn’t confirmed, Clean Air Zone money that runs out, and £16.6m more from a Children’s Trust placement budget that keeps overspending. All of it sits on a year forecast to be £9.5m overspent.
3: The Tyke put questions on all of this, drawn from the Council’s own reports, to officers and four Executive members ahead of the meeting, and not one of them answered.
4. There's no hint of free parking anytime soon
Bradford's minority Reform-led council administration faces its first serious challenge as it sets about developing a budget for 2027-28. The first report on this topic comes before the Executive tomorrow, claiming a £50 million savings plan. Impressed? No.
The public will be formally consulted on £3.58m of it. The Executive is asked to approve the other £46.42m on Tuesday 3 November. Before that meeting, The Tyke put questions to the Council's press office, the chief finance/S151 officer and his team, and to four Reform Executive members. Each had until close of business on Friday 30 October. Nobody answered. Cllr Ian Eglin, who is presenting the plan, declined outright, as part one reported. The rest didn't reply.
So here's what the documents say, and what is still unexplained.
Where the £50m comes from
Document T, the s151 officer's report, lists 42 proposals. The biggest block is the Bradford Children and Families Trust at £18.82m, 38% of the total, with £16.6m of it from placement costs. Corporate resources and financing contribute £11.69m, cross-cutting measures £8.25m and adult social care £5.95m. The rest comes to £5.29m. A good share is accounting, not cuts. The three biggest examples:
- £3.85m from packaging waste money under Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): £2.85m from assuming a bigger grant, "subject to confirmation by Government", and £1.0m from spending less of it
- £2.23m from a reassessed treasury management budget
- £1.18m from paying for existing work out of Clean Air Zone income
The report says between 20 and 99 council staff are at risk of redundancy.
Credit claimed, not earned.
Cllr Eglin credits efficiency for ending Exceptional Financial Support two years early. As part one set out, the s151 officer's own reports credit the Fair Funding settlement.
The public gets a say on 7%
Last year 16% of the savings went to public consultation. This year it's 7%: leisure income (£0.21m), the Localities service (£0.5m) and a 3% rise in fees (£2.87m). The other 39 proposals go straight to the Executive for approval, nine days before Corporate Overview and Scrutiny sees them on 12 November.
Document T §2.2 gives three grounds for not consulting: the proposal is the full-year effect of an earlier decision, has no material impact on residents, or has already been consulted on. Officers decide which applies.
The report's own equality assessment (Appendix 1) finds negative impacts concentrated in five areas: adult social care, digital and customer access, Localities, culture, sport and leisure, and residential care for children. Two of those five go to consultation.
I asked who decided which ground applied to each proposal, and whether that's recorded. No answer.
Six things the small print doesn't explain.
- Approve or note? Document T §5.2 asks the Executive to "note" the Children's Trust proposals. Recommendation (3) asks it to approve £46.42m of savings, a total that includes the Trust's £18.82m. I asked which it is. No answer.
- Clean Air Zone money with an end date. In July, the Month 2 report recorded a £0.5m overspend in Growth because CAZ income wasn't covering the work it was meant to fund (§2.53). Document T now books a £1.18m saving from the same switch, conditional on reversing a planned £0.53m cut and lasting only "to the end of the period when the CAZ funding remains" (§7.1). When CAZ income runs out, the cost comes back. I asked what changed between July and November. No answer.
- A grant counted twice. The £2.85m from a bigger EPR grant is "subject to confirmation by Government" (§8.8). The same pot is cut by £1.0m on the spending side (§6.5). I asked what happens if the grant comes in lower. No answer.
- Placements, again. The Trust overspent its placement budgets by about £9m in 2025-26. At Month 2, it faced £17.9m in placement pressure, including £8.7m of this year's savings already undelivered and a £7.1m forecast overspend. Document T asks for £16.6m more from placements in 2027-28. I asked what evidence supports that figure. No answer.
- What's in the clawback? £0.93m of growth money approved by Full Council in March is being withdrawn because it was never spent (§10.4). The report doesn't say which items. I asked whether the £0.4m Events budget, approved in March and cancelled in September to pay for reopening Sugden End tip, is among them. No answer.
- £50m out, £1.46m in. On the same agenda, Document S asks the Executive to note a new £1.462m spending requirement for the Bradford Rail and Southern Gateway programme over 2027-28 and 2028-29, about £3.4m over five years. It covers four new posts, finance and legal support, and £450,000 of consultancy in the first year. The budget will approve it in February. The report also flags "further capital expenditure and possibly the use of Council-held assets" for land assembly and highways, not yet costed.
Parking fines, cameras and other quiet switches
The plan doesn't change parking charges. Fines and enforcement are a different matter:
- £0.50m from penalty charge notices (§6.2). PCN income beat its budget by £1.1m in 2025-26 and is forecast to beat it by about £0.7m this year, so the budget is being raised to match. It's treated as a "realignment" and isn't subject to consultation. By law, surpluses from on-street parking enforcement can only be spent on transport, highways and related purposes (Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984, s.55). The report doesn't say where the extra money goes.
- £0.38m from more camera enforcement of moving traffic offences (§7.3). The first sites went live this year, and the plan assumes more will go live in 2027-28. The report says the figures "remain subject to confirmation" after an independent review.
- The 3% rise in "appropriate fees" (§10.3) doesn't say whether parking tariffs are included.
Elsewhere, costs are being moved rather than cut:
- £0.84m onto the ringfenced Public Health Grant: £0.59m towards corporate overheads (§3.8) and £0.25m for health and wellbeing grants (§3.6).
- £0.20m of staff costs moved to capital (§7.2). The Council funds its own share of the capital programme through borrowing.
These weren't among the questions I put to the Council. They're questions for scrutiny on 12 November.
A plan built on a year that isn't balanced
Document T assumes this year's finances stay within approved budgets (§1.7). The last published forecast, at Month 2 (31 May), put 2026-27 on course for a £9.5m overspend. The Trust was £7.1m over, adult social care £4.0m over, and £11.2m of this year's savings were expected to slip. I asked for the current forecast and when the next monitoring report goes to the Executive. No answer.
General Fund reserves, meanwhile, have risen from £198m to £251m, with £58.3m unallocated.
Questions, no answers
On 28 October, I sent eight questions to the Council press office, the s151 officer, the report's author, and the Director of Legal and Governance. I sent separate questions to Cllr Stephen Place and Cllr Andrew Judson (council tax, reserves and Squire Lane, Clean Air Zone policy), Cllr Jayne Morgan (adult social care and equality impacts) and Cllr Ian Eglin. Each question cited the Council's own documents. Each recipient had until close of business on Friday 30 October,
Cllr Eglin declined, as reported in part one. Nobody else replied.
Red flags
Beyond the matters I've briefly outlined above, plenty of details need explanation or debate. For example, it claims a £ 200,000 saving in staff costs. It achieves this by charging salaries to capital schemes. It takes £200,000 out of the revenue budget as a so-called saving. But Bradford's capital is largely borrowed. So a council is just shifting day-to-day costs onto borrowing.
As a related aside, Reform claims its leadership is well served with business people. I don't know what kind they were, but no business I ever worked with capitalised salaries unless those were directly related to a long-term asset and were within a defined budget. It's a tempting, dangerous practice that's easy to misuse. We need to stamp it out quickly before it becomes a habit.
My take
This is a worry. Budget setting is any council's most important job. Reform UK promised change and a programme to 'Save Broken Bradford.' At their first opportunity to shed light on legitimate concerns, the answer is... crickets.
Someone will be asking the same questions - will the Executive's approach be the same? If so, then budget setting will be more fraught than usual as opposition groups try and figure ways to present viable alternative proposals. I could understand reticence if my questions led into areas of debate the administration wants to keep to itself. But they weren't. Each question quoted a paragraph of the Council's own reports and asked what it meant. Officers write these reports. Executive members put their names to them. Neither group would explain them.
I suspect that the politicians have instructed officers to steer clear of public remarks at this stage. Officers will not be able to avoid them in the council chamber. Having watched the s151 officer on several occasions, and spoken with him directly in the past, I imagine he will be keen to explain his reasoning.
Reform's approach fits a pattern. In July the Executive voted to scrap Squire Lane and heard the s151 officer's risk warning only after the vote, then declined to revisit it. On Tuesday it's asked to approve £46 million of savings nine days before scrutiny sees them, with the questions about them still unanswered. Decide first, explain later. Or not at all.
One real difficulty is explaining how this 'stuff' works. For instance, most people think of 'savings' as cash. Councillors who should know better try to hoodwink residents by calling accounting tricks savings when they are really moving numbers around as illustrated above. In this case, strip out the accounting and the borrowed credit, and this plan asks very little of the public and tells it less.
The report's footnotes describe a grant nobody has confirmed, Clean Air Zone money with a shelf life, a Trust whose placement budget keeps missing, and a current year that isn't balanced yet.
Scrutiny meets on 12 November. The consultation runs to 16 December, on any proposal you like. Somebody should be asking these and many other questions.