Skip to content

Reform is aiming to grab a key Bradford council committee chair. Why you should care

Reform wants to chair a catch-all scrutiny committee that leaves it potentially marking its own homework. How is that happening, and why should you care?

Reform is aiming to grab a key Bradford council committee chair. Why you should care
sprinkling creative pixie dust

Even if the minutiae of a council’s political operation usually send you to sleep, who sits on and does what on committees is crucial for understanding how decisions affect Bradford residents. So strap in as I go through one example of why this matters in Bradford right now.

Wednesday promises to be an interesting day in the life of Bradford Councillors as they line up for the first ‘proper’ full council meeting since the 8th May elections delivered Reform with 29 seats (28 after one of their own resigned in disgrace). Regular readers will remember that Reform effectively did a deal with the Tories that allows Reform to operate as a minority administration. At the same time, the Tories and Labour divvied up control of the scrutiny committees. The first test of that kumbaya-inspired arrangement comes early on, as, under procedural matters, Reform wants its man, Robin Cumming, as the Chair of the Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee, replacing Tory councillor Paul Kirk.

One reading is that this is Reform’s first attempt to wrest control of a key scrutineering committee, which could raise concerns about transparency. I could, of course, be wrong, and Cllr Kirk has taken one hard look at the portfolios involved and thought ‘nah, not really.’ I’m not sure I blame him. Another reading is a bit more troubling.

When Reform took control, they rejigged the entire portfolio of activities. I accepted that there was a certain clear-eyedness to an arguably flawed approach. But I also warned that comparing who holds what across the two administrations only gets you so far — the new document outlining the portfolio arrangements doesn’t explain how scrutiny or officer leadership is meant to align with it. That gap hasn’t closed.

Bradford’s own description of what Corporate O&S actually does is telling: it’s responsible for corporate matters not falling within the responsibility of any other Overview and Scrutiny Committee — in other words, whatever’s left over once the other three committees have taken their share. It’s a catch-all defined by exclusion, which makes it a strange committee to hand to the very administration whose loose ends it’s meant to be catching. This control over a key committee underscores the importance of committee control in shaping local governance and accountability.

Reform could argue that, given the overlap in portfolios within the committee setup, appointing Cumming as chair, since he already sits on Governance & Audit, is a logical step to ensure a proper overview of how resources are accounted for. It is a persuasive argument, but it comes with one heck of an ask. As I have noted many times in the past, anyone coming from a business background, as Cumming is, and who thinks they will readily get a firm grip of public sector finance early on is in for a very nasty shock. They are worlds apart. And that’s just one of many issues that can trip up the unwary.

Call me sceptical, but given the litany of messes that Reform councils have gotten themselves into since 2024 - here is my Reform council cockup accountability tracker - handing over your homework for marking to someone who is also a member of the ruling party could create conflicts of interest. In short, a minority administration should not get to set and then mark its own homework on topics that directly affect the lives of 552,000 people. Put another way, will the people of Bradford trust an untested Reform group to be scrutinised by a chair who is conflicted by virtue of his whip? I am not so sure.

In the meantime, this one question and its voted outcome could easily soak up oodles of valuable time on an agenda item that has a whopping 32 questions and eight motions, all to be gotten through in six hours. More on that later as I set out the members’ questions and then the motions.

Now, if that doesn’t get you reaching for the popcorn, then….hmmm

Add The Tyke on Google