
That didn’t age well! In fact it didn’t age at all!!
It turns out that my last story about changes to the chair of the Bradford Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee was persuasive, but built on the wrong premise. Doh!
In framing the story as a power grab, I missed the fact that the council’s constitution says at Article 6.6.1:
“The Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee shall comprise ten members of Council and shall be chaired by a member of the political group that forms the Executive”
But then, it seems, others missed it too. I’ll get to that. For those who want the whole enchilada, that factoid is found on page 29 of a 341-page document, which is my excuse and not much of one. The point is that I got the constitutional position wrong.
As any self-respecting hack knows, having your story upended after the fact is the journalistic version of having a cream pie slapped on your face just as you’re congratulating yourself for a juicy exclusive.
So to the apology — especially to Cllr Kirk, whose mind I tried to second-guess, and to the Reform group. The AGM minutes show Reform Cllr Baker stood against Cllr Kirk for the chair in May and lost, even though the constitution says that seat should have gone to Reform without a contest. Cllr Cumming, taking over now, looks less like a power grab and more like Bradford’s rulebook finally being followed.
Is that the end of it? Not quite. How this cockup occurred is not answered in the agenda for this week’s full council meeting. What I can say is that the constitution was recently republished, and a trusted source close to the action tells me that the realisation that something is amiss was recent and that the city solicitor drew it to members’ attention after the AGM. I am rechecking this - just in case, and will update if anything material comes back.
Despite this self-inflicted humiliation, I remain concerned that someone from the ruling party should constitutionally chair a key committee. It is still a matter of ‘marking your own homework,’ a topic that raises suspicion in the public arena.
In the meantime, I have lines to write…Hmmmmm