Skip to content

Contradictions and U-turns at Bradford Council as the Sugden End tip readies for re-opening

As predicated, the Bradford Council Executive waved through the re-opening of the Sugden End tip, nuking a culture related pot in the process. But that’s not the end of the story.

Contradictions and U-turns at Bradford Council as the Sugden End tip readies for re-opening
Cllr Judson at Sugden End tip - via Bradford Council

The famous colloquialism ‘It ain’t over until the fat lady sings’ is appropriate, as the Reform-led minority administrative Executive at Bradford Council waved through what it thought was a slam-dunk decision to reopen the Sugden End tip at the expense of the £400,000 events budget. Hot news. It ain’t over.

As previously flagged, the Executive delivered on its promise to vote to reopen the tip, nuking the Events budget to do so. Except it isn’t quite like that. In fact, as I listened to the debated agenda item, the contradictions quickly mounted.

Conservatives to the rescue

Conservative councillors Winnard and Ahmed could hardly wait to express delight and claim credit for successfully campaigning on the matter, to the point of using the entire Events budget line item as the proposed funding source. Sure enough, it was included in their amendment to the in-year budget that was rejected in a full council vote 73-13 in March. Reform gets no credit there, then.

A downhill slide

Things only got worse as Labour contested the loss of the £400,000 Events budget line item. Reform council leader Stephen Place tried to deflect, saying the reopening of Sugden End was always in their plan. Was it? I’ve never seen evidence. Deputy leader Andrew Judson asserted that “nothing is actually lost”, an extraordinary claim given what the Council meeting records show. In Judson’s telling, the £400,000 is an unallocated growth line for which nobody had ever built a business case. Chief Executive Lorraine Donnel appeared to support that view, but Labour leader Imran Khan disagreed.

Labour kicks back

Khan pointed out that at the March 2026 Budget meeting, the full council voted specifically against the Conservative budget amendment, which included the £400,000. This means that while the Executive decided, on the chief legal officer’s advice, to seek confirmation from chief financial officer Mair regarding the legitimacy of managing the unfunded tip reopening in this manner, this is not a done deal. Khan quoted chapter and verse from the Council constitution that says a decision like this must go back to the full council. If Khan is correct, then expect to see this relitigated next month.

As if that wasn’t enough, Councillor Susan Fricker asked about the references to increased flytipping used as part of the reopening argument. Portfolio holder Councillor Ian Walker has previously said there is no evidenced direct link between increases in fly-tipping and household waste closures, a factoid contained in officers’ reports. On this occasion, he stressed that while increased fly-tipping may be a factor, it wasn’t the only issue at stake. Officers confirmed that while fly-tipping occurs across the district, they had not established a link between it and site closures.

Evidence? What evidence?

Fricker then pointed out that the evidence shows the benefits of investing in cultural activities and asked whether those considerations were weighed in the proposed decision. She asked:

There is clear evidence of the benefit of providing funding to local communities to put on cultural events. So, I would like to know from the Executive what evidence they have considered in looking at these recommendations, and I would also like to know what alternative financing options were looked at if the issue of reopening Sugden End is to be considered. What other options, other than removing this budget, were looked at?

Place tried to straight-bat by asserting that:

It hasn’t actually been allocated to anything. It was extra money. That’s why Councillor Judson made the point that nothing is actually lost. It was actually in the budget line, not allocated to anything. No business case has been made for it. We’ve simply moved it from being stagnant into something much more worthwhile for the people of Keighley. That’s it.

Unfortunately for Judson and Place, that is not the point, and Place got himself in a tangle by deflecting rather than answering the question directly. Worse still, Khan came back, pointing out that the March budget decisions are constitutionally affirmative for the Events budget, and therefore, to talk about a lack of business case is flat-out wrong.

My Take

Whether Sugden End should be reopened or not is not the point. Everyone agrees that if it can be open, then it should be. But as always, this is a matter of finance, and last time it was mooted, the answer was a decisive ‘no.’ The vote in March was 73-13 against the Conservative amendment, so hardly a ringing endorsement of their campaigning position.

It worries me that despite seemingly noble intentions, this administration seems content to U-turn on its stated aim of encouraging business at every opportunity when the narrative doesn’t suit its political intent. Raiding the Events budget was an easy option and one the Conservatives laid out for them before Reform was elected to any council position.

Listening to the debate during the Executive meeting, it is abundantly clear that Reform made no effort to consider alternatives. In that sense, spare funds likely don’t exist because, in the same meeting, Reform backed away from its promise to cut parking charges. Why? They can’t find the money.

So while Place likes to say he is not into political point-scoring, that is exactly how this decision looks. Check the language used by successive Reform and Conservative councillors and see if you agree.

Add The Tyke on Google