> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thetyke.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# The Draft Bradford Local Plan finally drops, complete with 177 issues
- URL: https://www.thetyke.com/the-draft-bradford-local-plan-finally/
- Published: 2026-10-12T06:23:20.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-26T13:39:41.000Z
- Description: A sloppy 1,290 page document laying out Bradford’s Local Plan iis already causing anger, It’s in draft but...?
- Author: Den Howlett
- Tags: Scrutiny, #suxless

Delivered late and already under attack, Bradford’s draft Local Plan 2026-43 is a 1,290-page mess. Among the 177 issues I believe I’ve identified, I counted spelling mistakes and typos on at least 83 pages. That’s unforgivable. They point to the kind of sloppiness that begs the question: are these people serious? What of the other 94 issues? I’ve categorised them under three broad heads: legal, fact-check, and hit and miss.

### Legal ambiguity

The Local Plan is a legally binding document that directly impacts people’s lives. It really does matter. If this plan is ‘unsound or legally defective, it will need serious attention. The Habitats Regulations Assessment test, which proves the plan won’t harm protected wildlife sites, is suspect. The plan says its wildlife assessment found it “can be delivered without adverse effects on the integrity of any European site” (p.304). Three pages later it says traffic pollution, one of the main risks to the moors, has “been addressed as part of the detailed testing and traffic modelling being carried out” (p.307).

Being carried out. Present tense. In the final draft. In fact the consultants’ assessment (Appendix 3) shows the modelling was done, so the plan’s own text is out of date. The assessment is more interesting than the slip. Its traffic figures were frozen in early June, before the council added sites and raised some site numbers, and the effect of those changes was “assumed” rather than re-run. And the result, that the plan would *reduce* pollution near most of the moors, is one the consultants call “counter-intuitive and hard to interpret”.

### Fact-checks

Pollution figures are stated in the wrong units. Four site pages, three in Manningham including the former Drummond Mills, put nitrogen dioxide at “30 parts per million” (pp.559, 562, 569, 689). The legal limit is 40 micrograms per cubic metre. Taken literally, 30 parts per million is more than a thousand times that: air nobody could live in. A units slip, in the very figures meant to protect future residents, is hardly cause for confidence-building.

The 228-home Tong Academy site is listed in Tong ward (p.662). Tong ward was abolished in the May 2026 boundary changes.

Three settlement policies cite Policies EN2 and EN3 (pp.460, 702, 911). There are none. NE2 and NE3 appear to be meant.

### Hit and miss

Any scheme of 50 or more homes needs a Health Impact Assessment (Policy ST4, p.93). 102 allocations qualify. Not one site page mentions it.

Twenty-eight site pages record a heritage assessment. Thirteen with listed buildings on site, or inside a conservation area, say nothing. They include Manningham Mills, Grade II\* and on the national Heritage at Risk register.

### What’s next?

At this stage, comments count only if they say the plan is unsound or not legally compliant, and explain why. “I don’t want houses here” will be set aside. “This site page says X, the evidence says Y, so the allocation isn’t justified” will not.

That is why the errors matter. Most people will respond about a site near them, and most of those sites are in the Green Belt. On my count, 73 allocations, about 6,980 homes, are taken out of the Green Belt. The questions worth asking about each one are the same kind this piece asks of the plan as a whole:

- **Is the evidence there?** Twelve Green Belt releases, about 520 homes, say outright that no landscape sensitivity assessment was carried out.
- **Did the council listen to its own experts?** On five sites, about 545 homes in Silsden, Ilkley, Bingley and Queensbury, the council’s own heritage assessment says the harm would be unacceptable. They are allocated anyway.
- **Is the site page right?** Check its ward, its numbers and the checks it asks for against what you know of the ground. If the page is wrong, say so, with the page number.
- **What does it need?** Most large sites promise only “proportionate contributions” to schools, GPs and roads. Ask which school, which surgery, which junction. This matters because the lack of adequate infrastructure provision ioftenft quoted as a problem in new developments,

### Residents are not best pleased.

Bradford has a poor reputation for Local Plan delivery, with frequent reference to past efforts as ‘over ambitious.’ This plan acknowledges that reality. I guess that at the upcoming Executive meeting on this matter, Deputy Leader Cllr Judson, whose lap this sits in, will defend the plan as more realistic. I expect to hear the Reform favourite words ‘common sense’ more than once, largely because the plan has substantially cut the number of houses to be developed. I also expect his introduction to attack past administration failures. That’s fair enough, but when you go on the attack, it helps if your own troops are lined up and polished ready to go.

Before he gets into the hot seat this week, Judson might reflect on some of the comments I’ve seen. One correspondent was particularly blunt: “No surprises there then because BMDC cannot even get road names right!” On footpaths and bridleways (yes, they matter too), another said: “A public right of way significantly lowers the value of land so the Council HAS to get it right & not bury its head in the sand or let landowners get away with unlawful elective diversions OR the public take liberties”

On specifics, a local councillor is concerned about Green Belt protection and says the local town council will make representations.

### My take

In fairness, most of the issues are cheap to fix. A units error, a dead ward name, a policy code with its letters swapped. Any of them alone would be a footnote.

But my experience watching this Reform administration in action suggests they have a ‘shoot first, ask questions later’ attitude toward policy announcements. This document has the same feel. It appears rushed to meet a vanishing deadline, with insufficient time and attention devoted to ensuring that at least the obvious areas of criticism are avoided. Other issues may be unavoidable, but Judson will struggle to make political points when his own report contains schoolboy errors. Judson should also be aware that my analysis raises more than 200 possible questions arising from ambiguities, errors, or odd decisions. And that’s before we get to the six-week public consultation window. It will be a bumpy ride.

### Endnote

[The source documents can be found here](https://www.bradford.gov.uk/planning-and-building-control/planning-policy/bradford-district-local-plan-submission-draft-regulation-19-executive-meeting-15-october-2026/?ref=thetyke.com), including the main item, Appendix 1\. Assuming the Executive passes the plan for public consumption on 15th October, the six-week consultation window opens on 19th October. I have ward-level detail for anyone interested. Hit me up.

P.S. - all typos here are mine. ;-)

[Subscribe](#/portal/signup)