> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thetyke.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Same question, same answer: Bradford's halal row returns for a third time
- URL: https://www.thetyke.com/same-question-same-answer-bradfords-halal-row-returns-for-a-third-time/
- Published: 2026-11-18T12:38:26.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T12:38:26.000Z
- Description: Cllr Debbie Davies has asked Bradford Council the same halal question, in almost the same words, twice in three years. The Tyke checks the figures, the history and the Reform reply against the record.
- Author: Den Howlett
- Tags: Division

Halal meat row

0:00

/617.637098

1×

Bradford's Conservatives want all halal meat supplied by the council to come from pre-stunned animals. They said so in the [Telegraph & Argus](https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/26737237.councillors-urge-halal-meat-policy-rethink-bradford/?ref=thetyke.com) this week.

Cllr Debbie Davies (Conservative, Baildon) blamed a policy approved "whilst under Labour control". Cllr Sally Birch (Reform, Windhill and Wrose), executive member for children and families, said she had already asked officers about non-halal provision for "Jews, Sikhs and other local children".

Both statements are deeply problematic.

### One question, three outings

Cllr Davies (who represents my ward) has been on riding this horse for a decade. The council's answers have hardly moved. Here is the history:

**March 2016, Full Council.** Cllr Davies asked whether schools serving halal offered alternatives for non-Muslim pupils. Cllr Susan Hinchcliffe told her that where the council caters, "a non-Halal meat alternative is always provided" ([T&A report](https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/14386579.council-catered-schools-that-serve-halal-meat-all-offer-non-halal-alternatives-bradford-education-chief-reveals/?ref=thetyke.com)).

**11 July 2023, Full Council, member question 33.** She asked whether all halal meat used by the council and in schools is pre-stunned, "given that around 95%" of UK halal is stunned first. The answer: the 1983 agreement with the Council for Mosques is for no pre-stunning, and "all children have a choice of school meal, and there is always a non-halal option".

**14 October 2026, Full Council, member question 106.** She asked the same question again, almost word for word, 95% included. The answer: no pre-stunning since 1983, repeated in the 2012 Halal Manual, with the supply chain certified by the HMC. 

The 2023 and 2026 wordings differ by two phrases: "please" and "from pre-stunned animals". Nothing else changed.

### The 95% that became 80% and is still questionable

I can find no official source for the 95% figure. Cllr Davies has now dropped it herself: her T&A statement says "well over 80 per cent".

The official number comes from the Food Standards Agency's [2024 Slaughter Sector Survey](https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/67c5cf0e750837d7604dbdbf/25-02-14%5FSlaughter%5FSector%5FSurvey%5F2024%5F%5FREVISED%5F.pdf?ref=thetyke.com) for England and Wales. Ministers [describe it](https://parallelparliament.co.uk/mp/daniel-zeichner/debate/2025-06-09/commons/westminster-hall/non-stun-slaughter-of-animals?ref=thetyke.com) as 88% of halal meat chickens being stunned before slaughter. The RSPCA applies the 88% to all halal animals.

- **Chickens:** 88% of halal chickens stunned. Because there are so many chickens, they drive the headline figure.
- **Sheep:** 29% of all sheep were killed without stunning in 2024\. Roughly a third of halal sheep were not stunned.
- **Caveat:** the survey covers one week in February 2024, in England and Wales only. The FSA warns that some issues may affect its reliability.

Her polling claim is weaker still. She says "80 to 85 per cent" of the public want non-stun slaughter banned. That echoes an RSPCA line from about a decade ago. The most recent poll I can find, by [More in Common](https://www.farminguk.com/news/debate-over-non-stun-slaughter-intensifies-amid-calls-for-reform%5F68230.html?ref=thetyke.com), puts support for a ban at 58%.

The evidence is not one-sided either. In August, the FSA's own animal welfare report [found](https://hyphenonline.com/2026/08/13/fsa-non-stun-slaughter-meat-animal-welfare-breaches/?ref=thetyke.com) no clear evidence that welfare breaches are more or less likely in non-stun slaughter than in stunned slaughter.

### A Labour policy? Try again, it's a Tory one

Cllr Davies says the council confirmed the policy was approved "whilst under Labour control". Neither the 2023 nor the 2026 answer mentions Labour. Both say only that the arrangement dates from 1983.

Bradford was not under Labour control in 1983\. The council was [hung from 1982 to 1986](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City%5Fof%5FBradford%5FMetropolitan%5FDistrict%5FCouncil?ref=thetyke.com), with Conservatives Tom Hall (1982–84) and Ronnie Farley (1984–86) as leader.

- **November 1982:** the Education Committee agreed to introduce halal meat in schools with at least ten Muslim pupils, according to an [Oxford COMPAS study](https://www.compas.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/RR-2008-Muslims%5FCohesion%5FBradford.pdf?ref=thetyke.com). Bradford was the first local authority in the country to do so.
- **September 1983:** halal meals began.
- **Who chaired the committee:** Peter Gilmour, "the young Tory chairman of the Council's Education Committee", according to Tony Grogan's 1989 account [The Pickles Papers](https://libcom.org/book/export/html/65950?ref=thetyke.com). Grogan says Gilmour "promoted innovations such as the provision of halal meat in schools in 1983".
- **Who objected:** among others, Labour's Norman Free, by the same account. So did Conservative members in Gilmour's own Keighley North ward.

The 2012 Halal Manual was produced under Labour, so that part of her claim stands. She also says the practice was backed "at the behest of the Halal Monitoring Committee". That can only apply to 2012 because the HMC was [founded in Leicester in 2003](https://halalfocus.net/?p=5883&ref=thetyke.com), twenty years after the policy began.

### The Reform reply answers a different question

Cllr Davies asked about stunning. Cllr Birch replied about choice. She told the T&A that "in recent weeks" she had asked officers about "ensuring provision of non-halal meat in schools".

The council has said twice that this provision already exists:

- **2016:** in council-catered schools, "a non-Halal meat alternative is always provided".
- **2023:** "all children have a choice of school meal, and there is always a non-halal option".

Her reasons don't stand up either.

- **Jewish children:** observant Jews can't eat halal meat, but they can't eat any non-kosher meat. Ordinary stunned meat is no more use to them than halal. [Jewish dietary law](https://www.chabad.org/library/article%5Fcdo/aid/3827328/jewish/Halal-vs-Kosher.htm?ref=thetyke.com) needs kosher provision, which she didn't mention.
- **Kosher meat is never stunned:** [all kosher meat in the UK](https://www.farminguk.com/news/debate-over-non-stun-slaughter-intensifies-amid-calls-for-reform%5F68230.html?ref=thetyke.com) comes from non-stun slaughter. The council's own 2023 answer says the religious exemption covers "the Muslim and Jewish faiths". In a debate about pre-stunning, Jewish children are the wrong example.
- **Sikh children:** this part is broadly right. The [Sikh Rehat Maryada](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kutha%5Fmeat?ref=thetyke.com) forbids ritually slaughtered meat, halal and kosher alike. It binds initiated Sikhs; practice among others varies.

### The line that went missing

The October 2026 council answer was given under the Reform administration. It drops one sentence from the 2023 version: the assurance that there is "always a non-halal option".

If the guarantee still stands, Cllr Birch is asking officers to secure something the council already promises. If it has gone, someone removed it, and parents have not been told. That would be a serious omission. 

I have asked the council's press office which it is. Any answer will be added here.

### My take

While I am not religious, I have Muslim family members, observant Jewish friends, including women who wear head coverings and with whom I am only allowed to shake hands. I also have friends who are Buddhist. While they may not agree on the details, they ALL prefer tolerance of others' beliefs and customs.

So when I first saw Cllr Davies formal question splattered on Facebook groups, I thought: "What on earth has this got to do with a council ward where there is no halal provision in schools?" There was a collective eye roll when I asked retired councillors the same question. Make no mistake, this is a culture-war question asked to a council that has given the same answer for 43 years. 

My suspicion is that it is posited in the hope of getting a majority on a motion yet to be forwarded, mandating a choice that is already there or, worse still, looking for an outright ban. I fear that intemperate Muslim councillors will see red (sic) and, in doing so, make the Tory case for them. 

The Cllr Davies version starts with non-existent or vague statistics and ends with a wrong history. The halal policy was a Conservative-chaired committee's idea. In 1983, it was proudly presented as good race relations. Blaming Labour for it now takes some chutzpah and reeks of irony. Treating the Council for Mosques' long-standing position as news is risible.

Reform's reply is worse, because Reform runs the place. The executive member promises to sort out a non-halal option the council says it already provides. After six months in the job and as a former Tory councillor before jumping ship to Reform, I have to ask, why doesn't Cllr Birch already know this? She cites Jewish children, who need kosher meat, which is never stunned. Then her own administration's written answer quietly drops the line guaranteeing that option. What she fails to note is that Muslims can consume kosher.

There's a genuine debate here. It covers animal welfare, the Equality Act, and the Lancashire stun-only precedent. Neither group is having it. 

**PS** \- I shall barbecue two qurbani chickens for my Muslim family Christmas dinner, served with Yorkshire pudding, roast potatoes, glazed carrots and (probably) red cabbage. Some traditions travel peacefully across time and space. Councillors who like culture wars might want to think about that.