The Labour-led Bury council’s relatively innocuous youth support motion has become a media football. Earlier this week, REFUK councillor Jack Rydeheard expressed his displeasure by being the only councillor to vote against the motion. Why? According to the Bury Times exhaustive reporting of the council meeting. Rydeheard had this to say to its reporters:
“My issue is the politicisation of this motion and that it was flawed.
“There are no actionable points in it and what was proposed can already be actioned without a vote.
“It was turned into PR stunt for the Labour party and I am surprised that the Conservatives voted for the motion given the politicised agenda of it.“
It is easy to write this off to political posturing - it is. On both sides. But be in no doubt: this Tory defector is dog-whistling as hard as possible in at least five directions:
- Media - obviously. Heck, look at me dissecting this!
- Other Tory councillors whose ‘opposition’ was understandable but mealy-mouthed by comparison in the context of the May elections.
- The REFUK base - yep. (Look at me showing how pointless this Labour administration is, wasting all our time and your hard-earned money, blowing smoke to disguise its own failings (whether real or imagined)—vote Reform at every opportunity.)
- The REFUK curious - these too. (I’m a lone voice standing up for you. Does this failing Labour administration have a deliverable plan, or is it more talk-talk? Conservatives can no longer trust the losers in its own ranks.).
- Towards REFUK HQ - yes boss, (I’m keeping in line and working my arse off to embarrass this bunch of Labour losers. Pity my old Tory chums aren’t on board. Yet.)
I bet that if the motion had not attracted the single REFUK vote, everyone would have forgotten about it the moment the chair said, ‘That is carried.’
Needless to say, once Bury Times hit the send button on their Facebook page, the REFUK attack posse moved in swiftly. I won’t bore readers with a repetition of now-familiar themes, insults, vague threats, and the like.
Who is really doing the politicking here? What does a Labour council facing elections in May do? There are 17 seats up for grabs, and you can be sure that REFUK thinks it can take them all. How does Labour course-correct without looking like it is having its ass handed to it on a topic that matters to voters?
If this plays well for REFUK, does Rydeheard become the next leader of a disruptive opposition? Quite possibly. He was the leader of the Tory group before jumping ship to REFUK and has a long history of political involvement, alongside vague references to taxi and private hire outfits.
Looking back over his reported record since being first elected in 2022, Rydeheard has always taken ‘principled positions’ that focus on a right-ish leaning Conservative vision. His tone grew much sharper after he joined REFUK in December 2025.
The degree to which Rydeheard’s words hit so many audiences suggests to me that this ‘protest vote’ was carefully and cleverly engineered in advance.
I am betting REFUK’s Millbank HQ had a hand in this. Why? Subtly and not so subtly sowing doubt is one of REFUK’s principal operating methods, always with a tinge of victimhood. Rydeheard’s words drip with that sense of victimhood which is so attractive to a certain demographic.
Labour prefers to trade facts. In doing so, it puts itself out of line with what voters care about. From then on, Labour is always on the defensive.
Labour could solve these problems by putting itself in the shoes of REFUK voters, preferably before issuing a press release or moving motions. That way, it could anticipate attacks and reframe onto turf it knows resonates with voters. But it doesn’t. Local mainstream media don’t have the resources to research these issues. As I have said before, they’ve become thoroughly enshittified. Sadly, Bury Times, which is part of Newsquest Media Group, is no different.
REFUK’s social media keyboard warriors and marketing teams (yes - this IS marketing Brand Reform) build smart narratives and deploy early-response systems to ensure their messages land as hard as possible. Labour doesn’t understand this. It instinctively knows social and alternative media are essential. But it makes the mistake of seeing voters in transactional terms, defaulting to using social media as an ad-driven play designed to support the election ground game. In REFUK’s world, the digital arena is the game.
Put another way, REFUK sees social media as a way to mediate outrage. It has a willing army of disaffected doomscrollers and bots to help them out. And let’s not mention the Russians. Oops! I just did. Add in an ad desperate media, and what do you have? Outsized leverage.
It just has one problem. When it gets into power, REFUK councillors are quickly exposed as hopelessly inexperienced and out of their depth. REFUK thinks it can ‘buy its way into competence. That is nonsense but is a story for another day.
In the meantime, what advice have you got for Labour councillors? Polite answers only please.