> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thetyke.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Reconciling Reform's budget contradictions
- URL: https://www.thetyke.com/reconciling-reforms-budget-contradictions/
- Published: 2026-11-04T10:19:58.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-05T00:04:30.000Z
- Description: At Tuesday’s Executive, Reform’s Executive members said one thing about the 2027-28 savings plan and their own budget said another. Four times.
- Author: Den Howlett

Bradoford Council Budget contradictions

0:00

/440.382041

1×

I am worried. While the Executive easily [approved £46.42m of savings for 2027-28](https://bradford.moderngov.co.uk/documents/g8729/Decisions%2003rd-Nov-2026%2010.30%20Executive.pdf?T=2&ref=thetyke.com), squaring what was said about it is much harder. These are not nitpicking issues, especially when the councillor tasked with managing the budget proposals promises a 'sustained reduction' in council tax while all indicators suggest a 4.99% rise is coming. This is just one of four contradictions, all of which matter for residents.

### Council tax: assumption up, promise down

Steven Mair, the council’s chief finance and s151 officer, presented the savings plan. Asked about council tax, he said a 4.99% rise was “purely an assumption”, carried over from the [Medium-Term Financial Strategy](https://bradford.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s55097/Executive%20Document%20BG.pdf?ref=thetyke.com) agreed in March. The Council will settle the figure next February.

That assumption isn’t new. Mr Mair’s statutory [report](https://bradford.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s55096/Executive%20Document%20BF.pdf?ref=thetyke.com) to the Budget Council meeting in March said the multi-year settlement would raise Core Spending Power by 46.9% by 2028/29, a figure that “assumes 4.99% Council Tax increase per annum.” Bradford’s recovery plan is built on council tax going up every year.

Cllr Ian Eglin, the Executive member responsible, closed his contribution by committing the administration to a “sustainable reduction in council tax.” He gave no figure, no timetable and no indication of savings or revenue assumptions that would pay for it. Before the meeting, I had asked Cllr Stephen Place and Cllr Andrew Judson whether the 4.99% assumption stands. [Neither answered.](https://www.thetyke.com/bradfords-50m-savings-plan-questions-asked-none-answered/)

### “Spend, spend, spend” or “successfully delivered”?

Cllr Place opened the item by blaming the previous Labour administration’s “spend, spend, spend”.Much later, and after councillors had raised questions, Cllr Eglin described most of the savings as a “continuation of existing programs that have been successfully delivered in the past.” He’s right. 

Mair's statutory report says the council “did not have a track record of delivering substantial revenue savings in full in recent years” but that “this has now changed." It credits the financial strategy agreed in March 2025, and £44.8m of savings delivered in 2024/25\. That was Labour’s strategy, run by Labour’s administration.

So the plan is inherited, it works, and it belongs to the people the Leader had just accused of “spend, spend, spend”. You can make one of those claims. Not both.

### The £120m is real. The story isn’t

Cllr Place told the meeting the last administration had left a “£120m deficit”. The figure is genuine. Mair's statutory report records a £120m overspend in 2024/25, £20m less than forecast, and covered by the government’s capitalisation direction.

The same report explains how it got there. National funding reductions since 2010/11 “disproportionately affected” Bradford, cutting its spending power by 24% in real terms, compared with an average of 15.9% for English councils. That, it says, “culminated” in the 2023/24 and 2024/25 overspends. [Our detailed analysis of how Bradford got here sets out the rest of the £391m.](https://www.thetyke.com/how-bradford-ended-up-with-391-million-debt/)

Cllr Eglin offered his own explanation. He accepted that underfunding was real, but said the crisis came to a head in 2023-24 because the council probably wasn’t “watching… closely”. Cllr Imran Khan (Labour) replied that the cuts made since 2010-11 now leave Bradford around £350m a year worse off. Cllr Eglin then narrowed his claim to unspecified things that “should have been managed better”.

### Parking: pledged, then parked

Cllr Rebecca Poulsen asked whether the three per cent rise in “annual fees and charges” includes parking, given Reform’s pledge to cut parking costs. Cllr Ian Walker said only that parking “will be included in the budget for next year.” Meanwhile, [the plan already books £0.5m more from penalty charge notices.](https://www.thetyke.com/bradfords-50m-savings-plan-questions-asked-none-answered/) Can you see the Council giving up that amount of income? 

Cllr Khan made the same point about leisure centre fees, which are rising despite an earlier promise to make them free. Nobody responded.

### And the press

Cllr Place accused the press of trying to “confuse and worry residents”. Cllr Eglin said this was “not the full budget, as seemingly been posed in the press”. The Tyke said plainly that this was the first stage of the budget. Make of that what you will.

### My take

One contradiction looks like a slip. Four look like a failed method: make a quick promise, then try to make it work in circumstances where they already know the budget is highly constrained.

Council tax is the sharpest contradiction. Both positions were stated in the same meeting, minutes apart, and the 4.99% isn’t a stray assumption. It sits under the recovery plan the administration inherited and now relies on. When Cllr Loy asked Cllr Eglin about a council tax reduction scheme, he said Mr Mair had already answered it and left it there. 

Cllr Eglin had arrived late to his own item, admitting he “maybe should have spoken a little bit earlier.”

The man fronting the savings plan can’t reconcile his party’s pledge with its own numbers. Worse, [he keeps dodging questions](https://www.thetyke.com/cllr-ian-eglin-wont-answer-questions-on-bradfords-50m-savings-plan-so-i-read-his-facebook-page/). When the detail came up, he handed it to an officer. In February, he won't have that luxury. There is a bigger problem.

When things go wrong, the public holds councillors accountable. When things go well, politicians quickly count the wins. The reality is that much of the credit should go to Mair's work managing the money, pushing back against councillors where appropriate, and recommending some of the toughest decisions Bradford council took in 2024-26\. [This administration has already chosen to ignore Mair](https://www.thetyke.com/bradford-council-executive-rejects/), handing itself a £5.6 million revenue loss. 

Does Reform's leadership understand the [ramifications of these decisions?](https://www.thetyke.com/will-labour-finally-save-bingley/) I'm not convinced. I hope I am spectacularly wrong because it will be residents who pick up the tab for any cockups.