Skip to content

Our local media is an enshittified mess - it needs euthanising

Our local media is an enshittified mess - it needs euthanising

My local rag, the Telegraph&Argus, affectionately known as the T&A, is a local media basket case that needs respite care before its inevitable demise.

Like many legacy media owned by the American giant Newsquest Media Group, the T&A exists as a slop shop that supports a Facebook ad driven business model. On a good day, it’s 164,000 Facebook subscribers get a few lines of passable reportage. On a bad day, they get stuff like this:

Some context. Bradford council has all out elections in May, 2026. The Labour led council holds a thin majority with 46 of 90 seats. Like many Labour councils, it is unpopular.

It doesn’t take a genius to conclude that a proportion of Facebook doom scrollers will jump onto the implied bait. The City Hall leading headline is as close an open invitation to splurge digital vomitus I’ve seen in oooh! A couple of days?!

Here is a sample of what some folk had to say:

The comments, however offensive, are hardly the worst thing in the world. That’s not the point. Here is the real headline when you click the link:

This is what the passably written opening paragraph of the story tells us:

A Bradford landmark is set to be lit up in red for a campaign to protect children’s hearts.

The difference between the headlines is night and day but the result is predictable. And that matters to business interests above anything else.

Local media Facebook headlines are frequently misleading. They drive latent outrage that is disproportionate and tangential to the real story.

Newsquest doesn’t care because they just want comments, likes and clicks. Triggering outrage with a juicy headline is the best way to achieve that. The headline bait approach also has the benefit of helping Facebook serve up more content for those who Facebook reckon is susceptible to that kind of content. Whether that means reciprocal value delivery back to the T&A is another matter. I doubt it. The road to total enshittification only goes one way. And the T&A is almost at the finishing line.

This is why my local media consumption has changed dramatically in the last several years.

My interest in local politics means that I want a smorgasbord of information that is as balanced as possible. I want to see serious effort at getting to the story behind the cold facts. What I don’t want are ads getting in the way of the story. As a consequence, I pay for much of what I read on subscription. For local issues, my go to list includes:

All of these digital only titles are well written. They exhibit a good balance between gravitas and brevity for the TL;DR: brigade. They share a ‘human’ style that rarely drifts into the anaemic reportage found in most legacy media. Thankfully, they steer far away from the outrage driven media. They often garner comment that adds value and nuance to the original story.

The only print publication I take is Private Eye. Rotten Boroughs and Reform Watch are not to be missed.

Consequences?

The tragedy of this particular story is that the campaign to combat Kawasaki disease is an important topic. A Gemini search says that while rare, Kawasaki disease is:

the leading cause of acquired heart disease in children in developed countries.

Yet that issue is largely lost under a fetid pool of ignorant slop. And all because the Facebook headline triggered a few more pence into both Newspeak Media and Facebook coffers. The cost? To media? Almost zero. To the well being of readers? Your guess is as good as mine. I’m betting it adds to the sense of hopelessness into which outrage led politicians lean.

Now if we could have something digital to displace the T&A…

What do you think? Do you believe we deserve better from media? If so, what does that look like?

P.S. Have I missed a good alternative to the T&A that’s not ad slop driven.

Add The Tyke on Google