On the journey home from last week’s Gorton & Denton by-election, I mused that, whatever the outcome, failed candidate Matt Goodwin and Reform UK (REFUK) would manufacture a win. And that’s exactly what happened, despite their coming in a distant second to a fresh-faced woman who exposed the racism and Islamophobia that was always going to trip up the candidate. What happened? Nothing. This was choreographed from the get-go.
First, REFUK’s leader and comms team lead Jack Anderton are a formidable team, churning out content that hits their talking points with precision. They are super smart at media manipulation and boss the social channels. Other political parties are clueless by comparison. I could easily imagine REFUK having at least two scenarios lined up once the result was declared.
In the first, they win, and crow about the electors abandoning their century-old Pavlov Dog habit of voting in Labour MPs in favour of an insurgent party and out-of-town candidate who promises to get rid of Muslims and people Goodwin defines as not British.
Matt Goodwin is so repugnant in his blatant Islamophobia that a win would have paved the way for REFUK to go much further in its demonising of others as a deflection from their real agenda - enriching mates like JC Bamford and themselves along the way, even if that means forgetting to declare earnings from time to time. So far, ‘othering’ has been a winning strategy that appears to have successfully baked in 20-25% of any vote. Whether that continues going forward is another matter, but right now, all other political parties see REFUK as a danger to be kept out of power at all costs. It is therefore no surprise to see organisations like Hope Not Hate collaborating with left-leaning parties.
In the second scenario, they lose and learn the limits of their ‘market power’ and their ability to mobilise voters. As a bonus, REFUK got to paint itself and its candidate as victims of voter fraud. Heard that before? Jan 6th, 2020.
The Goodwin Variation is plausible for those who already feel disenfranchised with a ready-made group of ‘others’ to whom sweeping generalisations about ‘family voting’ are glibly applied. While plenty of outlets attempt to debunk the idea, I can say as a matter of fact that some Muslim men answer for their wives when I asked for their voter details as part of our teller operation.
But as I said last week, I was far more impressed by the loud-mouthed REFUK-er proudly declaring that his entire family had come to vote for Goodwin. I wonder how many ex-Tory MPs/councillors who have defected to REFUK are Catholic. Why? The old joke is that the Catholic church is where Tories go to pray. Or what about observant Jews who are regular synagogue attendees and live by rules set by the Beth Din? Families tend to vote the same way regardless of political persuasion. It’s a non-story.
None of that matters to REFUK as it whines in any media willing to publish their crocodile-tear-stained press releases. Goodwin goes one step further, writing a cringeworthy electoral obituary in The Spectator that demonstrates a man whose obnoxious self-obsession is on display for all to see. The catchily titled: Did I ever really stand a chance in the by-election? seems more concerned with his live life:
To my surprise, the campaign also offered lessons in love. I gave a quote to a newspaper about my blossoming relationship with Eilidh Hargreaves, features director at Tatler, and how (unfortunately for her) we spent our first Valentine’s Day canvassing. The quote led to us trending on X thanks to some incel lefties who run an account called ‘Reform UK Exposed’.
If he thought that might humanise him, then Goodwin is sadly mistaken. He goes on:
“Family, Community, Country” campaigner divorced only last month,’ it raged. Really? Eilidh and I met more than three years after my separation – at The Spectator Parliamentarian of the Year Awards no less. In any case, the attempted hit-job backfired as politicians and journalists rushed to our defence. ‘Ha ha!’ remarked one shrewd commentator. ‘Having an attractive and successful girlfriend will increase Goodwin’s popularity, you complete spanners.’ Indeed.
Pass me the motion discomfort bags. These words are truly vomitworthy.
It doesn’t take long for Goodwin to stand up his fraud theory. In the process, he aligns himself with that section of people who know nothing about other cultures but are frightened and angry that ‘foreigners’ and specifically Muslims are invading the UK:
Some evenings, I canvassed streets where nobody spoke a word of English. Nor was it uncommon to find a large number of foreigners living in a home that, according to the official register, was inhabited by one British couple.
Despite Goodwin’s background as an academic, there is nothing remotely academic about this crude line of thinking. But that doesn’t matter. What matters is that voters see a clean-cut, booted and suited white Brit whose claim to an MP's seat was thwarted by the UK equivalent of untermenschen. It’s a hideous picture, but it’s worked well so far.
How well victimhood will work as a political sleight of hand in the future is up for stress testing in the country-wide May 7th local elections. One thing is for certain. REFUK and Goodwin have done progressives a favour. While REFUK may have discovered the upper level of their support when fielding one of their most grotesque Islamophobes, REFUK can no longer credibly say that, at their core, they are not racist. And you can be sure that the social histories of their candidates will be forensically examined by opponents with all the finesse of a roughly executed anal probe. After all, electors won’t want to vote in blatantly racist representatives. Or do they? We shall see.
Oh - wait a mo’ - Labour just beat REFUK in Murton, county Durham. And of course, REFUK-ers are taking it badly. As they always do.