> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thetyke.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Is Bradford Council’s Reform leadership having its Hannibal Lecter ‘confused’ moment?
- URL: https://www.thetyke.com/is-bradford-councils-reform-leadership/
- Published: 2026-10-07T07:26:55.000Z
- Updated: 2026-10-26T13:45:11.000Z
- Description: Bradford council’s flag protocol comes up for revamping just as Black History Month gets underway. Meanwhile, Reform want to nuke Bradford’s City of Sanctuary status. Are you confused? You should be!
- Author: Den Howlett
- Tags: #Migrated-1792703212526, #suxless, #Import 2026-10-22 21:12, Leadership

At the beginning of Bradford’s minority Reform UK-led administration, [I argued that the leadership was a tad confused](https://www.thetyke.com/bradford-council-leaders-mass-of/). Now, after the gyrations it’s had to sort out its botched flag-protocol decision, alongside the welcome to Black History Month, flying the Nigerian Independence Day flag is bad enough. Add in the proposed dumping of City of Sanctuary status because Cllr Ian Walker, portfolio holder for neighbourhoods and communities, wants a debate on mass migration. Add it up and what do you have? A scene out of the 2001 film Hannibal where Lecter is seen lobotomising the evil Krendler, saying:

> Are you confused? Then I’ll decide for you, if you’ll permit me.

Moviegoers will know that Krendler becomes increasingly confused and unhinged to the point where Lecter cuts him down with:

> Paul, if you can’t keep up with the conversation, you better not try to join in at all.

That's pretty much how I see the incoming culture war from this Reform-led group. And here's the thing: Lecter's line isn't a gag. It is, near enough word for word, what the Executive meeting supporting report does. Full Council has been found too cumbersome to decide. "Not considered practical," says the report. So the protocol decides for it: every flag request in the district now lands on one man's desk. Are you confused? Then he'll decide for you. Except the "if you'll permit me" has been quietly deleted along with the clause requiring a full Council vote, which is plausibly what got the motion through in July at all. Let me explain.

### Flags, no flags and some flags?

At July’s full council meeting, a Conservative-led flag protocol motion, as amended by Reform, squeezed through, leaving many council property flag-flying protocols subject to full council decision. Since then, Jason Field, the chief legal and monitoring officer, has said the proposed approval method is impractical.

That is all well and good except the protocol now vests every future flag decision in whoever holds the Leader's office. The current holder is Stephen Place, whose [pre-election Instagram output I documented in July](https://www.thetyke.com/all-change-here-as-reform-uks-bradford/) — screenshots below — and which was the subject of a code of conduct complaint that Field declined to investigate.

This is the same Jason Field who drafted the new protocol as chief legal officer and self-assessed its equality impact as "neutral" on the sole ground that any deleted flag can come back if Place decides it should. That is even though Place has already acknowledged that some flag-flying decisions are inevitably political.

Whether that compromise was Field's own pragmatism or arrived with encouragement from the leadership is not something the published papers disclose. Who benefits is not in doubt.

![1cc70487-4981-42a2-a711-41e36f3bdf7c_1464x1430.jpg](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d7/42/d7420f54-0624-45fc-8c4a-f26cf61ed058/content/images/2026/10/74c4f5eb-fb91-45bc-ad43-0848be997fd7_1456x1422-jpeg.jpg)

Stephen Place’s Instagram account

So goodbye International Women’s Day and the Pakistani or Palestinian flags? Will Pride flags survive? And what about Black History Month (BHM), at the beginning of which, last week, Lord Mayor Chris Herd attended the raising of the Nigerian Independence Day flag outside City Hall as [proudly noted and photographed by the Windrush Generation Facebook page](https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=2318796502277045&set=pcb.2318796575610371)

![f6170d67-bfc5-4238-8062-24ad2edf0eec_2084x1506.jpg](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d7/42/d7420f54-0624-45fc-8c4a-f26cf61ed058/content/images/2026/10/eb9249aa-40ed-4fbd-a237-c649699dfb54_1456x1052-jpeg.jpg)

Lord Mayor Chris Herd with Windrush Bradfordians at the beginning of Black History Month

### The ironies mount up.

There is an irony to say nothing of confusion that later this week, the Reform-run Council Executive will pass the future decision back to Place. Which way will they go? A clue might come from the words of Cllr Ian Walker, Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhoods and Communities, [who said, as it relates to BHM:](https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/26598872.flag-raising-marks-start-black-history-month-bradford/?ref=thetyke.com)

> This is a packed programme of events to suit all ages and interests which reflects and celebrates the valuable contributions and achievements of our African and Caribbean communities and to mark Black History Month.

Which, of itself, is odd because Walker is also the proposer of the upcoming City of Sanctuary debate wherein Walker wants to get rid of Bradford’s status as a recognised City of Sanctuary. He has acknowledged that it is not a cost issue, but because he wants a debate on mass migration. Eh? How does that make sense when, for a start, Bradford has no say on mass migration and is, in fact, bound by law in what it can and cannot do?

And then you have Cllr Birch, Executive Member and Portfolio Holder for Children and Families. In 2022, Birch, who then was a Conservative councillor, [was loud and proud (sic) in her support of Ukrainian refugees:](https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/20142476.bradford-councillor-sally-birch-invites-two-ukrainian-refugees-wilsden-home/?ref=thetyke.com)

> Councillor Sally Birch, of the Bingley Rural ward, opened her door to two Ukrainian women after signing up to the Homes for Ukraine scheme.  
>  
> The two women are cousins, aged 32 and 26, and preferred to stay anonymous.  
>  
> Cllr Birch, who lives in Wilsden, said the two ladies – who have both secured part-time jobs and are taking lessons to improve their English – already feel like they fit in.  
>  
> “The community has given them an amazing welcome, but I wouldn’t have expected anything less”, she said.

What does she say now?

Or what about Cllr Jayne Morgan, Executive Member and Portfolio Holder for Healthy People, who enthusiastically promoted the Bradford Flower Carpet with [multiple Facebook posts](https://www.facebook.com/share/r/1DmeHRDXsM/), garnering thousands of likes and hundreds of positive comments?

![4c9ee65a-39f3-4326-b04c-0e9f3f48e07a_1148x934.jpg](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d7/42/d7420f54-0624-45fc-8c4a-f26cf61ed058/content/images/2026/10/941ca887-ea34-4c04-a35e-a17c3d811ef1_1148x934-jpeg.jpg)

Bradford Flower Carpet

Local artist Shiraaz Ali designed the flower carpet. It attracted an estimated 80,000 people. Everything I have seen strongly suggests that the Flower Carpet was a cultural triumph for the city. Does Reform really want to open a culture war as a pretext to defund cultural activities or support for activities it doesn’t like? How then will it respond to [remarks Ali made to the BBC:](https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwg7k4rzz5eyo?ref=thetyke.com)

> The design has been a wonderful process, starting at the museum, which explores Bradford’s heritage and how the city has developed over time, and what makes it what it is today in 2026.  
>  
> The design is really geared at looking at the origin of Bradford and how it has developed as a textile city, its history, and its people who’ve made all the textiles. Thousands of people.

### My take

You can trace a bright line from July to the present day, and out to an upcoming full council debate, to see how Reform plans to launch its assault on Bradford’s multicultural society while cherry-picking the ‘in’ and ‘out’ groups it chooses to support or ditch.

![17ddc4d3-7fe5-44be-ae6e-cb99650dfbe5_1125x1393.jpg](https://storage.ghost.io/c/d7/42/d7420f54-0624-45fc-8c4a-f26cf61ed058/content/images/2026/10/a80772dc-f581-49ab-a456-1ee7ffa0f102_1125x1393-jpeg.jpg)

In that context, I’d remind all councillors that Bradford stands proud to have been active supporters of the Kindertransport, using the old Carlton Hotel as a base to house and support children fleeing the Nazi regime. Or what about the more recent [effort by Muslims to save the last remaining Bradford synagogue?](https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/dec/20/bradford-synagogue-saved-muslims-jews?ref=thetyke.com)

So here is the question Thursday’s Executive meeting vote cannot answer, and the sanctuary motion will force: **what is Bradford for**, according to this administration? On the current record, they want the £1bn visitor economy, the Flower Carpet crowds, the Mela, the Turner Prize footfall and the retirement of every symbol of the communities that produce them. That’s not balance. It’s a short position on your own asset.

It is perhaps worth reminding ourselves what Conservative councillor Paul Sullivan, [who originally proposed the flag protocol changes](https://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/26298631.council-votes-limit-flags-can-flown-city-hall/?ref=thetyke.com) said at the time:

> Bradford has no foreign policy jurisdiction, and currently our flag flying protocol is riddled with anomalies and tensions that can be inflamed.  
>  
> Do we mark all serious illnesses with a flag day, or only AIDS?  
>  
> Why do we celebrate Women’s International Day (sic) but not celebrate Men’s Day?  
>  
> Divisive flag flying has caused discord in many areas.  
>  
> I note a venue in Texas has removed Pride Day and replaced it with Family and Faith Day. We commemorate the Windrush affair; many residents view this as selective tokenism.

What does he have to say to Cllr Falak Ahmed, whose register of interests records her husband's membership of the Pakistan Club, a body that describes itself as…

> …non-political and non-religious that aims to provide a positive vehicle for the Pakistani heritage people in the UK to celebrate their special cultural days, provide a neutral platform for people of similar interests and tastes to interact and also to counter some of the more negative perceptions created about the Pakistani diaspora in the UK

So…are you confused?

[Subscribe](#/portal/signup)