Skip to content

"I don't" is Bradford Council Leader's response to call for apology

An unashamedly unapologetic Leader stonewalled repeated questions about his questionable social media history.

The ‘deny, deny, deny’ approach made famous by Trump doesn’t work in the UK. When Stephen Place, now leading a minority Reform administration in Bradford, faced questions at the first full council meeting after the May election, he followed the same strategy, trying to deflect questions back at those asking them.

After Reform won the most seats in the May elections, people quickly focused on Stephen Place’s social media history. It’s not a good look. This issue was bound to come up at the first full meeting after the elections, and it did

My preview flagged Question 10 — Cllr Susan Fricker asking Leader Stephen Place whether he’d posted sexually explicit material, and material derogatory to people of a particular race or religion, on his personal Instagram — and predicted fireworks if she got a supplementary.

She got one. The fireworks lasted two seconds.

The written answer

Fricker’s question, submitted in advance:

“Does the Leader of Council confirm that he posted on his personal Instagram account ‘@StephenPlace5’ (i) sexually explicit material and (ii) material that is derogatory to people of a particular race or religion?”

The written answer didn’t touch it:

“This is the first full council meeting since 7th May. I would have thought that Councillor Fricker would have used this opportunity to ask a question relating to her constituents, her ward or indeed something affecting the wider Bradford district.”

This wasn’t a one-time thing. The same sentence, almost word for word, started the answers to two more personal questions in the same agenda pack: one from Cllr Caroline Firth about whether he believes the moon landing was faked (Q16), and another about “chemtrails” (Q30). Three direct questions, three identical refusals to answer. That’s not just being evasive; it’s following a script.

One more thing in the written record, easy to miss: earlier the same evening, answering a question on whether council employees face disciplinary action for posting hateful content, the Council committed to zero tolerance — sanctions “up to and including dismissal.” Nothing in the agenda pack says that the standard applies to elected members, including the Leader.

Cllr Fricker was never going to be satisfied with that kind of non-answer, so she had another go, this time in the chamber.

The supplementary

Fricker didn’t just repeat her question. She set the stage by reminding everyone that public servants, including councillors and police officers, must follow the Nolan Principles of public life: accountability, honesty, and leadership. Then she asked again, directly: did he post the material, and if so, what does that mean for the Council’s zero-tolerance policy on hate and discrimination now that he is in charge?

Mentioning the police wasn’t just for effect. Place used to be a police officer. By naming police officers alongside councillors, Fricker placed the standards of his former job right next to those expected of him as Leader.

The verbal answer

He waited until she’d finished, paused, then said:

“I don’t.”

Just two words. He didn’t explain or respond to anything Fricker had just said.

It’s not clear what those two words actually deny, even after hearing them. The most obvious answer is to “Did you post it?” But the question also asked whether, if he did, he would accept what that means. His reply doesn’t make it clear which part he’s rejecting. It’s possible Place didn’t hear everything Fricker said, since he has hearing issues and sometimes struggles with City Hall’s sound system. You can listen to the recording at the top of this story and decide for yourself.

The pattern

There were three written questions and three identical dodges. Then came one live question, answered with as few words as possible. Yet earlier that evening, in his own report to Council, Place had plenty to say. He called May’s AGM committee votes a “grubby back room deal” and warned that opposition parties “still seek to damage and ridicule with puerile playground antics.”

I would be very surprised if the women and minorities targeted on his Instagram account would agree with the ‘puerile playground antics’ characterisation. Unless, of course, Place is forgetting the adage: when you point the finger, there are always three pointing back.

Add The Tyke on Google