On 30 July, Bradford Council announced plans to scrap charges for parking and leisure services under Council Leader Stephen Place’s Reform-led administration. To no one’s surprise, this announcement was widely lauded on social media as a welcome reversal of an unpopular imposition by the previous administration. Privately, some councillors in the village areas told me they are happy that what they saw as a borderline nutty policy is being rolled back. Local to me, businesses and those needing to make village centre pickups have always been deeply resentful of a policy they see as punitive that directly impacts them. All good? Not so fast. There’s just one niggly problem.
What wasn’t announced is what that will cost — or what’s being given up. The answers coming back from the Council can be safely filed under ‘woolly thinking.’ It doesn’t help that triangulating the moving parts that make up ‘parking’ as a revenue generator are, shall we say, quite literally, in motion.
The Council published figures tell only part of the story. Parking fines (PCNs) have climbed steadily from around £1m in 2020/21 to roughly £3.5m in 2025/26. That trend alone raises a question worth asking: if enforcement income has been rising this fast, what happens to it once the charges being enforced disappear?
The bigger figures — actual income from pay-and-display machines and pay-by-phone parking across the district for the last two financial years — are harder to pin down. The Council Statement of Accounts, signed off in April this year, doesn’t break parking income out separately; it’s folded into the wider Department of Place budget. The most detailed public breakdown available, obtained under the Freedom of Information Act and dating to 2023/24, puts combined on-street and off-street income at just under £3m for that year alone — before PCN income is added.
When I approached Bradford Council press office for the 2024/25 and 2025/26 figures, along with any modelling of the cost of the free-parking policy, the response provided no numbers. Instead, a Council spokesperson said the parking proposals would be treated as a “key decision,” already destined for the Council forward plan, with “all the other information” to appear in a report to the Executive “published a week before the meeting.” Duh?
Historic income data doesn’t need to wait until a future decision is made public. Bundling it in with forward-looking policy modelling, which councils can more legitimately hold back while a decision is live, looks less like caution and more like control over when, and how, the numbers finally surface. Like it or not, that timing could make scrutiny harder.
Why “key decision” status matters
When Place made the announcement, some people asked why the Council can’t ‘just get on with it?’ Under the regulations governing how councils operate, a “key decision” is one likely to involve significant spending against a budget, or to have a significant effect on communities in two or more wards. A parking and leisure charging change reaching across the district plausibly satisfies both tests independently — which means it also triggers real procedural requirements. A pain to many, a safeguard for us all.
Bradford Council’s constitution covers this point. Decisions falling outside the approved budget require sign-off from both the chief finance and legal officers before proceeding; if either raises doubts about compliance, the matter must go to full Council rather than be settled by the Executive alone. Any budget virement over £100,000 also requires full Council approval, unless the three largest group leaders agree unanimously.
None of that is unusual process — it’s exactly what should happen before a decision with district-wide financial consequences is taken. But it means the coming weeks matter. The Executive’s report is expected around 1 September; the decision itself is scheduled for 8 September. Between now and then, Bradford residents — and the councillors being asked to approve the policy — are entitled to know what the free-parking pledge will actually cost the authority, and where that money is coming from.
At the time of writing, the Council has not provided the historic income figures requested, nor confirmed whether a full financial impact assessment exists ahead of the Executive report’s publication. It’s hard to read this as anything other than a deliberate bet that the policy’s popularity will outrun scrutiny of its cost.
I cannot see either of the top opposition parties standing in the way of what will be a popular policy. There’s no political mileage in doing so. However, as is always the case with Bradford Council, decisions that have a significant financial impact will need to be assessed. The fact that no historical figures were offered is a red flag in its own right.
Watch this space.
In the meantime, it will be nice to visit my barber with good news for him and his clients.