Conventional wisdom says that when standing in a bucket of crap, don’t jump up and down or you’ll end up stinking more than you already do. That’s pretty much what the Labour Party leadership did this weekend.
The frustration in Adam Bienkov’s surgical analysis of Labour’s decision to refuse Andy Burnham the chance of entering his name on a selection longlist for a vacant Parliamentary seat is palpable:
If Starmer and his team really knew how to transform the government’s fortunes then they would have nothing to fear from Burnham, or any other big beast re-entering national politics.
The fact that they are so determined to keep him out shows that the opposite is the case.
This is a big problem for those of us campaigning in the May local elections. In my crude analysis, we have three main doorstep topic areas: local, district and national.
In most local election scenarios, councillors who demonstrate tangible results have little to fear from re-election events. But this is 2026, and the same rules don’t apply. Reform UK has made sure of that by setting the political news agenda ahead of the Labour government.
Our local councillors and candidates know their turf and the concerns of the residents they represent. They are loath to big themselves up in the public domain; they’re more interested in service and community. It shows in their support for the myriad events and community groups in their wards. It shows in the small successes that matter to people in their everyday lives. These councillors and candidates have civic pride and duty etched into their being.
District issues are trickier. We’ve had years of service and financial cuts. Try explaining next year’s likely 4.99% council tax increase against the backdrop of this year’s eye-watering 9.99% jump to an already hard-pressed and tired electorate. An electorate in which city centre poverty tips over 50% in some places, while a few miles away, yet part of the district, is the Sunday Times 2025 best place to live in the UK.
There are many positives to share as campaigners meet residents on campaign days. Much-needed regeneration is working, but the cost issues don’t go away.
Our turn as City of Culture in 2025 was a success. Depending who you choose to believe, upwards of three million visitors pumped millions extra into our local economy. But the memory of those tax hikes, coupled with massive infrastructure expenditure, is hard to square away.
And then there is the national story over which we have no control and precious little influence. Sadly that includes the grooming gang scandal. This month, one of the high-profile victims presented a petition to our council demanding that our area be at the ‘heart’ of the upcoming national grooming gang inquiry. Grooming gangs are fertile ground for our political opponents, especially Reform, which we expect will field some rabid individuals, determined to sow division.
So when I hear that the NEC has effectively nuked Andy Burnham’s chances of being selected, let alone elected in Gorton and Denton, I have to ask: what planet are these people on? What are they thinking when the opportunity to return one of the most able and demonstrably successful Mayors is squashed? I am not alone. The Guardian notes:
Simon Opher, the Stroud MP who is part of Labour’s 2024 intake, called it “petty factionalism” from Starmer’s aides.
“The voters of Gorton and Denton are being denied the opportunity to choose a brilliant candidate to represent them in parliament, and this risks gifting the seat to Reform in the run-up to the local elections,” he said. “We desperately need to be better than this.”
How can our leadership ignore the chance to bring fresh, radical energy to the top table? It is barking mad.
How do they expect campaigners to answer the inevitable questions about the government’s leadership? I don’t know. What do I do when I see opposition online campaigners taking the piss? I’ve been consistently critical of what I see as poor communications. This is something else.

This is incompetence and fear at the heart of government. It is a political miscalculation of the first order that has chief adviser Morgan McSweeney’s paw prints all over it. For those of us on the ground, the stink of fear is corrosive to morale; it signals a leadership more interested in internal gatekeeping than in the radical energy we need to sell on the doorstep, leaving local activists feeling like an afterthought in a defensive war they never signed up for.
To quote Bienkov:
As I have set out on these pages before, Farage and Reform are eminently beatable, whether it be under Burnham, or any other Labour figure not tied to the disastrous Blue Labour experiment we are now watching unfold.
But in order to prevent the calamity of Farage in Downing Street, Labour must first abandon McSweeney’s 0% strategy and start rebuilding the coalition of support that got them into power in the first place.
Doing so is more than possible. Doing so under the leadership of Starmer and his current advisers, simply isn’t.
Bienkov is correct. Voters deserve better. We all do.
In the meantime, we will double down on our local and district stories, hoping that voters won’t care too much about parochial Labour Party antics. Somehow, I doubt we will be afforded that luxury.