This is a long read with lots of detail so if your attention span is less than five minutes, then here is the TL;DR:
Bradford keeps its sanctuary status by one vote (37–38). Reform argued its motion on cost, then its own finance portfolio holder admitted “there is no data” on what the status costs.
Cllr Sally Birch recast her record of hosting Ukrainians as evidence the Homes for Ukraine scheme was “abused.” Official figures don’t support her claims about failed checks and abuse of housing and the NHS.
Reform voted down the Conservatives’ offer of a review, 15–64, then lost outright. It fits a pattern of deciding first and doing the homework later, so the coming budget will need close scrutiny.
Yesterday morning, I said Reform’s sanctuary motion wasn’t about money and that the homework hadn’t been done. Last night’s debate proved both points, and the vote settled it. Some of what I wrote yesterday held up. One prediction didn’t.
Not about money, and now officially no data
My earlier story noted that Cllr Ian Walker had told the Yorkshire Post the motion wasn’t about saving money, and that the status costs £700 over three years. He said the same again in the chamber. Cllr Sally Birch then built her speech in support almost entirely on cost. She said: “There is no such thing as a commitment without a consequence… What does it cost? What does it achieve? Can we afford it?”
You’d think someone had the answer. Au contraire: Cllr Ian Eglin, who holds the finance portfolio, told the chamber, “I’ve asked for the data on exactly what it costs, and there is no data. We don’t collect that data.”
I said Bradford’s motion named no figure. It turns out the council doesn’t have one.
The copy-and-paste charge reaches the chamber.
The earlier story showed that the motion closely followed one Reform passed in Calderdale in July, with the review, the dignity clause and the line accepting that asylum is the government’s job all removed. Its three precedents didn’t stand up either. Calderdale’s wording was gentler, Sandwell’s celebrated migrants’ contribution, and Sunderland, according to its local sanctuary group, never had the status.
Cllr Ishtiaq Ahmed put it more bluntly on the floor: “When you copy and paste motions from Reform headquarters in Sunderland, Calderdale and Sandwell, you are not engaging in any meaningful debate.”
Cllr Birch explains herself by rewriting the story.
Yesterday, I wrote that Cllr Birch, who hosted Ukrainian refugees in her home, had some explaining to do. Birch’s own speech closed on her hosting two Ukrainians “under the Homes for Ukraine visa scheme” as first-hand experience of pressure on local services. It soon became clear that explanation wouldn’t be enough, as speaker after speaker named her.
Labour group leader Cllr Imran Khan read out what she told GB News in 2022: “We are a city of sanctuary, and it felt incumbent on me to do the right thing.” Khan called the motion “an insult to Councillor Birch’s actions from 2022” and asked the Leader to allow a free vote. Cllr Joe Wheatley asked how, as children and families portfolio holder, she could vote to make it harder for Ukrainian refugees to integrate.
In her personal explanation, Birch said she had hosted because the government assured her new arrivals would be checked through the Home Office and Interpol, and “those checks were found failing.” Running a support network for hosts in her ward gave her “exposure to dozens of these cases.” Many people had “abused” the route. It “damaged my faith and trust in the asylum route… It made me scared.” She described “abuse of the NHS system, abuse of housing allocations.”
Birch’s claims don’t stand up.
Birch’s response doesn’t pass the sniff test. Homes for Ukraine is a visa scheme, not an asylum route, as she herself said forty minutes earlier. And it has nothing to do with Local Authority of Sanctuary status. The claims themselves are serious, from a Cabinet member responsible for children and families. But as is often the case with Reform, her argument came with no hard evidence. So I looked into it myself.
According to the National Audit Office’s 2023 investigation, 2,516 of about 66,000 safeguarding checks failed. Those were checks on sponsors, and some “failures” were withdrawn applications. So her claim that checks on arrivals “were found failing” doesn’t match how the scheme worked.
The NAO found eight per cent of Homes for Ukraine households in England had been homeless or threatened with homelessness by August 2023, mostly after hosting arrangements ended. That’s evidence of strain on the scheme, not abuse. Fewer than one per cent of households were rematched for safeguarding reasons. I found nothing showing Ukrainians got priority in housing allocations: they became eligible to apply, which isn’t the same thing.
In fairness, these numbers are a tad out of date, and if Cllr Birch wants to provide fresh data, I am happy to print what she claims.
“One Bradford”, then “uncontrolled mass migration.”
Yesterday, I suggested Leader Stephen Place had a conflicted mind: talking about bringing Bradford together while letting hard-line motions through. Last night he told the chamber the motion was “not a motion against compassion, humanity, or helping people who are fleeing war and persecution,” and spoke of “one Bradford.”
Then Cllr Walker used his right of reply to say what the motion was really about: “The motion is about uncontrolled mass migration into the United Kingdom. It is a political motion.”
Cllr Wheatley’s point of order asked where the motion’s resolutions mention uncontrolled migration. They don’t. Walker went on to say City of Sanctuary welcomes people “regardless of criminal record.” Cllr Khan said that was categorically untrue and asked for it to be withdrawn. The Lord Mayor ruled it “not quite a point of order.”
Where I got it wrong
I expected the Conservatives to do Reform’s heavy lifting and turn withdrawal into a review the administration could live with. They tried. Their amendment, moved by Cllr David Ford, would have sent the question to scrutiny with an officer report on costs and benefits first. Reform and every opposition group voted it down, 15 to 64.
Cllr Peter Kirk had warned what that would mean: “If they vote against our amendment, they’re effectively saying they don’t think they can get it through.” Reform’s Cllr Oliver Bolton-Williams called the amendment “…little more than a wrecking amendment designed to kick this decision into the long grass.” Reform chose all or nothing. It got nothing, and the Conservatives split three ways on the motion itself, presumably on a vote free of the Conservative whip.
My take
This was a motion often argued on cost by an administration that admits it has no cost data, moved by a councillor who says it isn’t about money, and defended as being about something the motion didn’t say.
It fits the pattern I keep identifying. Sugden End’s £400,000 moved on a business case still marked “draft”. Squire Lane voted down before the finance chief’s warnings were heard. A flags protocol called “neutral” by its own equality check and “deliberate” by the councillor in charge. Add a sanctuary motion with no numbers behind it, conflated with ‘mass migration.’ That’s not bad luck. That’s how this administration works.
The Conservatives offered Reform a way to do the homework and move forward. Reform turned it down. It doesn’t help when you accuse your usual helpers of trying to “kick this decision into the long grass” when, in reality, they were just looking for scrutiny.
Finally, I expected fireworks and feared some councillors might struggle to keep their tempers in check on a motion they suspected was race and/or ethnic baiting. Thankfully, all speakers kept their composure, but it is fair to say that Cllr Anna Watson’s words that withdrawal would send “a message to every refugee family in this city that they are not wanted here” hung heavily in the chamber.
For now, the debate is over, but that doesn’t mean Reform will not find ways to defund programmes they don’t like. They’ve done it before; they’ll try again. Scrutiny committees will need to keep a close eye on the upcoming budget.